🪷 Bhagavad-Gītā · 15.4
Chapter 15 · पुरुषोत्तमयोग · Puruṣottama-Yoga · "The Yoga of the Supreme Person" · Verse 4 of 20
🪷 English Translations
Five authentic English voices · each from a distinct sampradāya · together revealing the verse's full śabda-tattva.
Shri Purohit Swami · Poetic English · 1935 · public domain · Cosmo Press tradition
15.4 Beyond lies the Path, from which, when found, there is no return. This is the Primal God from whence this ancient creation has sprung.
Swami Sivananda · Direct prose · Divine Life Society
15.4 Then That goal should be sought for, whither having gone none returns again. I seek refuge in that Primeval Purusha Whence streamed forth the ancient activity or energy.
Swami Gambīrānanda · Word-key glosses · Advaita Ashrama · Śaṅkara-school
15.4 Tatah, thereafter; tat, that; padam, State of Visnu; parimargitavyam, has to be sought for, i.e. realized; gatah, going, entering; yasmin, where, into which State; they na, do not; nivartanti, return; bhuyah, again, for worldly life.
As to how It is to be sought for, the Lord says: Prapadye, I take refuge; tam, in that; adyam, Primeval-existing from the beginning; purusam, Person, who has been mentioned by the word State; eva, Himself. The search has to be carried on thus, i.e., by taking refuge in Him.
Who is that Person? That is being stated: Yatah, from whom, from which Person; prasrta, has ensued, like jugglery from a magician; purani, the eternal; pravrttih, Manifestation, the magic Tree of the World.
What kind of persons reach that State? This is being answered:
Swami Ādidevānanda · Śrī-Vaiṣṇava perspective · Rāmānuja school
15.3 - 15.4 The form of this tree, having its origin above, i.e., in the four-faced Brahma and branches below in the sense that man forms the crest through continual lineage therefrom, and also having its branches extended above and below by actions done in the human state and forming secondary roots - that form of the tree is not understood by people immersed in Samsara. Only this much is perceived: 'I am a man, the son of Devadatta, the father of Yajnadatta; I have property appropriate to these conditions'. Likewise, it is not understood that its destruction can be brought about by detachment from enjoyments which are based on Gunas. Similarly it is not perceived that attachment to the Gunas alone is the beginning of this (tree). Again, it is not perceived that the basis of this tree is founded on ignorance which is the misconception of self as non-self. Ignorance alone is the basis of this tree, since in it alone the tree is fixed.
This Asvattha, described above, firm-rooted, i.e., the roots of which are firm and manifold, is to be cut off by the strong axe of detachment, namely, detachment from the sense objects composed of the three Gunas. This can be forged through perfect knowledge. As one gains detachment from sense-objects, one should seek and find out the goal from which nobody ever returns.
How does this attachment to sense-objects, which consists of the Gunas and erroneous knowledge forming its cause, cease to exist?
Sri Krsna now answers:
One should seek 'refuge (Prapadyet) in the Primal Person' alone in order to overcome this ignorance. One should seek refuge (Prapadyeta) in Him who is primal, namely, the beginning of all entities, as stated in the following text: 'With Me as the Lord, the Prakrti gives birth to all that which moves, and that which does not move' (9.10), 'I am the origin of all; from Me proceed everything' (10.8), and 'There is nothing higher than Me, O Arjuna' (7.7). From Me, the creator of everything, has streamed forth this ancient activity, continuing from time immermorial, of attachment to sense-objects consisting of Gunas. This has been declared already by Me: 'For this divine Maya of Mine consisting of the Gunas is hard to break through. But those who take refuge in me alone shall pass beyond this Maya' (7.14).
Or a variant of this stanza is 'prapadya iyatah pravrttih' (in place of 'prapadyet yatah pravrittih'). This gives the sense that this discipline of taking refuge in the Supreme Person for dispelling of ignorance has continued from a distant past. The tendencies of ancient persons seeking liberation are also ancient. The purport is this: The ancient liberation-seekers, taking refuge in Me alone, were released from bondage. [This can be taken to mean that Prapatti or taking refuge in the Lord had originated in the Bhakti tradition of the Sri-Vaisnavites from ancient sages i.e., from the Alvars who preceded Ramanuja by several centuries. It is not a creation of Ramanuja].
Dr. S. Sankaranarayan · Academic precision · modern scholarly
15.4. Then that Abode must be sought, having reached Which one would not return. [The Yogin] would attain nothing but that Primal Person from Whom the old activity (world creation) commences.
🪷 English Commentaries · The Ācārya Voices
The classical commentary tradition rendered in English · each ācārya speaks from their own sampradāya · the seer chooses the depth of darśana.
Swami Sivananda · Verse-by-verse word-keys with Sanskrit anchors
15.4 ततः then? पदम् goal? तत् That? परिमार्गितव्यम् should be sought for? यस्मिन् whither? गताः gone? न not? निवर्तन्ति return? भूयः again? तम् that? एव even? च and? आद्यम् primeval? पुरुषम् Purusha? प्रपद्ये I seek refuge? यतः whence? प्रवृत्तिः activity or energy? प्रसृता streamed forth? पुराणी ancient.Commentary That which fills the whole world with the form of ExistenceKnowledgeBliss is Purusha. Or? that which sleeps in this Puri (city) of the body is the Purusha.Singleminded devotion which consists of ceaselessly thinking of or meditating on the Supreme Being is the sure means of attaining Selfrealisation. Taking sole refuge in the Primeval Purusha is the means to know or realise that supreme goal goind whither the wise do not return again to this world of death.The aspirant should know the abode of Vishnu. He should struggle hard to reach it. He should seek it by taking refuge in the Primeval Purusha. If he reaches this immortal abode of Vishnu or the imperishable Brahmic seat of ineffable splendour and glory he will never return to this mortal world.The Primeval Purusha or the pure? Supreme Being Who is ExistenceKnowledgeBliss Absolute is the goal or the supreme abode or the abode of Vishnu. Just as illusory objects like elephants? horses? etc.? come forth through the jugglery of the magician? so also this ancient energy or the original divine power or emanation of this tree or illusory Samsara has streamed forth from that Primeval Purusha.What sort of persons reach that goal eternal Listen.
Swami Gambīrānanda · Advaita-school commentary (Śaṅkara tradition)
15.4 Tatah, thereafter; tat, that; padam, State of Visnu; parimargitavyam, has to be sought for, i.e. realized; gatah, going, entering; yasmin, where, into which State; they na, do not; nivartanti, return; bhuyah, again, for worldly life.
As to how It is to be sought for, the Lord says: Prapadye, I take refuge; tam, in that; adyam, Primeval-existing from the beginning; purusam, Person, who has been mentioned by the word State; eva, Himself. The search has to be carried on thus, i.e., by taking refuge in Him.
Who is that Person? That is being stated: Yatah, from whom, from which Person; prasrta, has ensued, like jugglery from a magician; purani, the eternal; pravrttih, Manifestation, the magic Tree of the World.
What kind of persons reach that State? This is being answered:
Swami Ādidevānanda · Rāmānuja Śrī-Vaiṣṇava commentary
15.3 - 15.4 The form of this tree, having its origin above, i.e., in the four-faced Brahma and branches below in the sense that man forms the crest through continual lineage therefrom, and also having its branches extended above and below by actions done in the human state and forming secondary roots - that form of the tree is not understood by people immersed in Samsara. Only this much is perceived: 'I am a man, the son of Devadatta, the father of Yajnadatta; I have property appropriate to these conditions'. Likewise, it is not understood that its destruction can be brought about by detachment from enjoyments which are based on Gunas. Similarly it is not perceived that attachment to the Gunas alone is the beginning of this (tree). Again, it is not perceived that the basis of this tree is founded on ignorance which is the misconception of self as non-self. Ignorance alone is the basis of this tree, since in it alone the tree is fixed.
This Asvattha, described above, firm-rooted, i.e., the roots of which are firm and manifold, is to be cut off by the strong axe of detachment, namely, detachment from the sense objects composed of the three Gunas. This can be forged through perfect knowledge. As one gains detachment from sense-objects, one should seek and find out the goal from which nobody ever returns.
How does this attachment to sense-objects, which consists of the Gunas and erroneous knowledge forming its cause, cease to exist?
Sri Krsna now answers:
One should seek 'refuge (Prapadyet) in the Primal Person' alone in order to overcome this ignorance. One should seek refuge (Prapadyeta) in Him who is primal, namely, the beginning of all entities, as stated in the following text: 'With Me as the Lord, the Prakrti gives birth to all that which moves, and that which does not move' (9.10), 'I am the origin of all; from Me proceed everything' (10.8), and 'There is nothing higher than Me, O Arjuna' (7.7). From Me, the creator of everything, has streamed forth this ancient activity, continuing from time immermorial, of attachment to sense-objects consisting of Gunas. This has been declared already by Me: 'For this divine Maya of Mine consisting of the Gunas is hard to break through. But those who take refuge in me alone shall pass beyond this Maya' (7.14).
Or a variant of this stanza is 'prapadya iyatah pravrttih' (in place of 'prapadyet yatah pravrittih'). This gives the sense that this discipline of taking refuge in the Supreme Person for dispelling of ignorance has continued from a distant past. The tendencies of ancient persons seeking liberation are also ancient. The purport is this: The ancient liberation-seekers, taking refuge in Me alone, were released from bondage. [This can be taken to mean that Prapatti or taking refuge in the Lord had originated in the Bhakti tradition of the Sri-Vaisnavites from ancient sages i.e., from the Alvars who preceded Ramanuja by several centuries. It is not a creation of Ramanuja].
Dr. S. Sankaranarayan · Modern academic scholarship
15.4 See Comment under 15.5
Swami Chinmayānanda · Chinmaya Mission · modern Vedantic teaching
।।15.4।। कहीं ऐसा न हो कि कोई विद्यार्थी इस रूपक के वास्तविक अभिप्राय को न समझकर उसे कोई लौकिक वृक्ष ही समझ लें? गीताचार्य भगवान् श्रीकृष्ण कहते हैं कि जैसा वर्णन किया गया है? वैसा वृक्ष यहाँ उपलब्ध नहीं होता। पूर्व श्लोक में वर्णित अश्वत्थ वृक्ष इस व्यक्त हुए सम्पूर्ण जगत् का प्रतीक है। सूक्ष्म चैतन्य आत्मा विविध रूपों और विभिन्न स्तरों पर विविधत व्यक्त होता है जैसे शरीर? मन और बुद्धि में क्रमश विषय? भावनाओं और विचारों के प्रकाशक के रूप में और कारण शरीर में वह अज्ञान को प्रकाशित करता है। आत्मअज्ञान या वासनाओं को ही कारण शरीर कहते हैं। ये समस्त उपाधियाँ तथा उनके अनुभव अपनी सम्पूर्णता में अश्वत्थवृक्ष के द्वारा निर्देशित किये गये हैं। अत यह कोई परिच्छिन्न वृक्ष न होने के कारण कोई इसे एक दृष्टिक्षेप से देखकर समझ नहीं सकता है।कोई भी पुरुष इस संसार वृक्ष का आदि या अन्त या प्रतिष्ठा नहीं देख सकता। यह वृक्ष परम सत्य के अज्ञान से उत्पन्न होता है। जब तक वासनाओं का प्रभाव बना रहता है तब तक इसका अस्तित्व भी रहता है? किन्तु आत्मा के अपरोक्ष ज्ञान से यह समूल नष्ट हो जाता है। बहुसंख्यक लोगों द्वारा इन आध्यात्मिक आशयों को न देखा जाता है और न पहचाना या समझा ही जाता है।इस संसार वृक्ष को काटने का एकमात्र शस्त्र है असंग अर्थात् वैराग्य। भौतिक जगत् जड़? अचेतन है। इसके द्वारा जो अनुभव प्राप्त किया जाता है? वह चैतन्य के सम्बन्ध के कारण ही संभव होता है। जब तक कार के चक्रों का सम्बन्ध मशीन से बना रहता है तब तक उनमें गति रहती है। यदि प्रवाहित होने वाली शक्ति को रोक दिया जाये? तो वे चक्र स्वत ही गतिशून्य स्थिति में आ जायेंगे। इसी प्रकार यदि हम अपना ध्यान शरीर? मन और बुद्धि से निवृत्त करें? तो तादात्म्य के अभाव में विषय? भावनाओं तथा विचारों का ग्रहण स्वत अवरुद्ध हो जायेगा। तादात्म्य की निवृत्ति को ही वैराग्य कहते हैं। यहाँ उसे असंग शस्त्र कहा गया है। भगवान् श्रीकृष्ण अर्जुन्ा को उपदेश देते हैं कि उसको इस असंगशस्त्र के द्वारा संसारवृक्ष को काटना चाहिये।हमारी वर्तमान स्थिति की दृष्टि से उपर्युक्त अवस्था का अर्थ है शून्य? जहाँ न कोई विषय हैं और न भावनाएं हैं न कोई विचार ही हैं। अत हम ऐसे उपदेश को सहसा स्वीकार नहीं करेंगे। भगवान् हमारी मनोदशा को समझते हुये उसी क्रम में कहते हैं? तत्पश्चात् उस पद का अन्वेषण करना चाहिये? जिसे प्राप्त हुये पुरुष पुन लौटते नहीं हैं।उपर्युक्त सम्पूर्ण विवेचन का निष्कर्ष यह निकलता है कि निदिध्यासन के अभ्यास के शान्त क्षणों में साधक को अपना ध्यान जगत् एवं उपाधियों से निवृत्त कर उस ऊर्ध्वमूल परमात्मा के चिन्तन में लगाना चाहिये? जहाँ से इस संसार की पुरातन प्रवृत्ति प्रसृत हुई है।यदि इस उपदेश को केवल यहीं तक छोड़ दिया गया होता? तो अधिक से अधिक वह एक सुन्दर काव्यात्मक कल्पना ही बन कर रह जाता। आध्यात्मिक मूल्यों को अपने व्यावहारिक जीवन में जीने की कला सिखाने वाली निर्देशिका के रूप में? गीता को यह भी बताना आवश्यक था कि किस प्रकार एक साधक इस उपदेश का पालन कर सकता है। इनका एक व्यावहारिक उपाय है? प्रार्थना। जिसका निर्देश इस श्लोक के अन्त में इन शब्दों में किया है? मैं उस आदि पुरुष की शरण हूँ? जहाँ से यह पुरातन प्रवृत्ति प्रसृत हुई है।यह श्लोक दर्शाता है कि जब हमारी बहिर्मुखी प्रवृत्ति बहुत कुछ मात्रा में क्षीण हो जाती है? तब हमें अपनी बुद्धि को सजगतापूर्वक संसार के आदिस्रोत सच्चिदानन्द परमात्मा में भक्ति और समर्पण के भाव के साथ समाहित करने का प्रयत्न करना चाहिये। इस आदि पुरुष का स्वरूप तथा उसके अनुभव के उपाय को बताना इस अध्याय का विषय है।किन गुणों से सम्पन्न साधक उस पद को प्राप्त होते हैं सुनो
🪷 Place in the Bhagavad-Gītā
- This is verse 4 of 20 in Chapter 15 · Puruṣottama-Yoga (The Yoga of the Supreme Person)
- Chapter theme: BG 15.7 mamaivāṁśo jīva-bhūtaḥ · BG 15.18 puruṣottamaḥ · climax of non-duality
- Ṣaṭka grouping: ANTYA-Ṣaṭka (BG 13-18 · the resolution)
- Chapter hub: /purushottama-yoga
🪷 ॐ नमो भगवते वासुदेवाय 🪷
सर्वम् कृष्णार्पणम् — this verse is one maṇi (jewel) on Krishna's thread (BG 7.7)